By Jack Haire, Finatal
Having spent three years recruiting CFOs into private equity-backed businesses, followed by the last three years focused on the Office of the CFO (OCFO) across the US, I’ve become increasingly convinced that hiring beneath the CFO can be just as challenging, if not more so, than hiring at C-suite level.
One of the most consistent conversations I’m having with US private equity sponsors and portfolio company CFOs is around the difficulty of recruiting and retaining strong finance leaders beneath the CFO.
Sponsors rightly dedicate significant time and resources to securing the right CFO. Yet the individuals sitting beneath them are critical to delivering the investment thesis and, in many cases, represent the next generation of PE-backed CFOs.
I believe the standard of search should reflect that.
From my experience, four trends are making this market particularly challenging.
Compensation and equity expectations continue to rise
These are genuine value creation hires, and proven PE-backed talent comes at a premium, particularly those who have delivered through an investment cycle. The level of compensation required can surprise sponsors and CFOs, but reflects the competition for experienced talent.
Equity is no longer reserved for the CFO. Candidates increasingly expect to share in the value they create, with potential payouts and proximity to a liquidity event significantly influencing their willingness to move.
Competition from CFO searches is intensifying
One of the most interesting developments I’ve seen in the US market is the willingness of PE firms to consider strong CFO-1 talent for their CFO appointments.
This is reflected in Finatal’s wider placement data, with 40% of our CFO appointments over the past two years going to first-time CFOs, a trend Jamie Irwin, Partner on Finatal’s CFO desk explores in his recent article on stepping into the CFO seat.
A significant proportion of the senior finance leaders we speak to are already involved in CFO processes. Sponsors recruiting a VP Finance or Head of FP&A are therefore often competing directly with opportunities offering candidates their first CFO seat.
Retention goes well beyond making the hire
The PE-backed CFO seat is one of the most coveted positions in finance, and many ambitious CFO-1 and CFO-2 leaders are making deliberate career moves toward that goal.
This creates a genuine challenge for sponsors. They want to recruit individuals capable of becoming CFOs, but also need them to remain committed to their current role throughout the investment cycle.
Understanding those ambitions and offering credible progression is essential to securing and retaining the right people.
AI is creating further uncertainty around hiring
We’re increasingly seeing hiring managers question how AI will reshape the Office of the CFO, particularly which responsibilities at CFO-1 and CFO-2 level could be automated and what capabilities will become more important.
It’s a broader discussion, but that uncertainty is already complicating decisions around role design, candidate requirements and the skills businesses should be investing in for the longer term.
Why does this make the market so difficult to recruit in?
When you consider all of the above, it’s no surprise that US private equity firms are struggling to recruit at this level.
The challenge isn’t necessarily a lack of capable talent, but the sheer size of the market and the speed at which it moves.
Candidate circumstances, career ambitions and competing opportunities can change remarkably quickly. With significantly more roles, specialties and career paths across the Office of the CFO, that complexity is multiplied compared with the CFO market itself.
It’s an incredibly fluid market, where successful recruitment requires constantly having your finger on the pulse, not just knowing who is available when a search goes live.
Why we’ve invested in a dedicated US OCFO practice
This is exactly why we’ve built a dedicated Office of the CFO practice at Finatal, with a team focused exclusively on hiring beneath the CFO across the US.
Since January 2025, we’ve partnered with over 40 private equity sponsors on OCFO appointments across their US portfolio companies, spanning a broad range of industries and businesses ranging from $50m to over $1bn in revenue.
Across Finatal globally, we’ve made nearly 250 OCFO placements since January 2026, reflecting the scale and importance of this market. Alongside our wider CFO search capabilities, this gives us a strong understanding of the talent landscape across senior finance leadership.
Despite the variation in business size, industry and role, the same challenges have consistently emerged.
It’s why we’ve committed dedicated resources to engaging with this market beyond live searches, continuously tracking how talent moves, how candidate motivations evolve and where future opportunities to attract the right individuals may emerge.
I believe searches across the Office of the CFO require the same investment in specialist market intelligence, dedicated resources and long-term thinking as CFO searches themselves.
Not only because of the importance of these appointments today, but because many of these individuals will become the CFOs leading these businesses, or the next generation of portfolio companies, tomorrow.
If you’re a US private equity sponsor or portfolio company CFO looking to strengthen your finance leadership team, I’d welcome a conversation about the talent market and how our dedicated OCFO team can support your hiring plans.